In New Zealand, education is compulsory for all children between the ages of 6 and 16 under Section 35 of the Education and Training Act 2020 (the Act)[1]. To educate a child outside the state or registered private school system, parents must obtain a formal Certificate of Exemption from the Ministry of Education (Te Tāhuhu o te Mātauranga) pursuant to Section 38 of the Act[1].
The threshold statutory test codified in Section 38(1) is rigorous: the designated officer of the Ministry must be satisfied that the child will be taught “as regularly and as well as in a reasonably convenient registered school”[1]. Once an exemption is granted, parents are entitled to claim the government Home Education Supervisory Allowance. However, if the Ministry receives substantiated complaints or possesses reasonable grounds to believe that instruction has deteriorated, it can refer the family to the Education Review Office (ERO / Te Kahu Tōkeke) for a formal independent audit under Section 457[2]. Understanding the mechanics of ERO audits, portfolio preservation, and revocation defense is vital for New Zealand home educators.
The Section 38 Statutory Standard: “As Regularly and As Well”
Section 38(1) of the Education and Training Act 2020 establishes that the Secretary for Education may grant an exemption from enrolment at a registered school upon application by a parent[1].
The application dossier requires extensive documentation addressing two distinct statutory prongs:
| Statutory Criterion | Meaning Under MoE Regulatory Guidance | Evidentiary Requirement in Application Dossier |
|---|---|---|
| “As Regularly” | Consistency and frequency of instruction | Weekly timetable, annual instructional schedule, routine learning rhythms |
| “As Well” | Breadth, depth, and quality of education | Curriculum resources, pedagogical philosophy, assessment methods, and progressive goals |
| Learning Areas | Broad coverage across core domains | English, Mathematics & Statistics, Science, Social Sciences, Arts, Health & PE, Technology |
| Learning Environment | Safe, resourced learning space | Access to libraries, digital tools, science equipment, community co-ops, and athletic clubs |
| Progress Recording | System for monitoring academic growth | Work samples, reading records, project files, and mastery assessments |
The Ministry’s national guidelines explicitly acknowledge that “as well” does not require copying the New Zealand Curriculum (NZC) or mimicking classroom teacher lesson structures[3]. Parents are entirely free to adopt classical, Charlotte Mason, Montessori, Waldorf, or self-directed approaches, provided the plan articulates coherent educational progression suitable for the child’s age, ability, and aptitude[4].
The Role and Mandate of the Education Review Office (ERO)
The Education Review Office (Te Kahu Tōkeke) is the Crown review agency tasked with evaluating the performance of schools, early childhood services, and home educators. Under Section 457 of the Act, an ERO review officer may review the education of any child exempt under Section 38 upon request by the Ministry of Education[1].
Unlike schools, which undergo regular scheduled multi-year ERO reviews, home educators are reviewed by ERO only on a targeted referral basis. Referrals typically arise when:
- The Ministry receives persistent notifications from health or welfare agencies suggesting educational neglect.
- The family fails to submit the mandatory bi-annual supervisory allowance declarations confirming ongoing instruction.
- Serious allegations arise regarding the total cessation of schooling.
When ERO accepts a referral, an assigned Review Officer contacts the family to arrange a formal audit[2].
The ERO Audit Protocol: Documentation and Review Methods
An ERO home education review is an evidentiary audit designed to verify whether the child continues to be taught as regularly and as well as in a registered school[2]:
1. Advance Notification and Scope
The review officer must provide reasonable advance notice in writing, outlining the scope of the review and requesting preliminary documentation. The review may occur at the family’s home, an ERO regional office, or a mutually agreed community facility.
2. Evidentiary Dossier Review
During the review conference, the officer examines tangible documentary evidence:
- Work Portfolios: Chronological binders of child-produced work, writing samples, mathematical calculations, and science lab notebooks.
- Reading and Media Logs: Lists of fiction and non-fiction literature, research materials, and digital learning platforms accessed.
- Instructional Timetable: Documentation demonstrating consistent educational routines throughout the academic year.
- Feedback and Progress Logs: Records indicating how parents diagnose learning hurdles and provide remedial guidance.
3. Student Engagement and Discussion
The review officer typically converses with the child in a relaxed, non-threatening manner about their projects, interests, and books. The purpose is not to administer graded psychometric testing, but to observe whether the child exhibits genuine familiarity and pride in the work contained in their portfolio[2].
The ERO Findings Report and Ministry Remediation
Following the audit, the ERO review officer drafts an official Home Schooling Report that is transmitted simultaneously to the parents and the Ministry of Education[2]:
| ERO Audit Finding | Regulatory Consequence | Ministry Action Required |
|---|---|---|
| Satisfactory Progress | Confirmation of Exemption | Ministry closes file; Supervisory Allowance continues uninterrupted |
| Areas for Improvement | Advisory Recommendations | Parents submit supplementary evidence or adjustments within 60 days |
| Unsatisfactory / Inadequate | Serious Concerns Documented | Ministry initiates formal notice under Section 38(4) regarding potential revocation |
If ERO issues an adverse finding, the Ministry cannot immediately cancel the exemption without affording procedural fairness. Under Section 38(4) of the Act, if the Secretary is no longer satisfied that the child is being taught as regularly and as well, the Ministry must issue a formal warning notice specifying the perceived deficiencies and granting parents a reasonable operational timeframe to implement remedial measures[1].
Only if follow-up reviews confirm continued non-compliance can the Ministry issue a formal Certificate of Revocation, requiring school enrolment under Section 35[1].
Legal Remedies and Ombudsman Inquiries
If a family faces an unjustified or procedurally flawed ERO audit or Ministry revocation, several legal avenues provide relief:
- ERO Reconsideration: Parents can submit formal written objections to ERO’s draft report before it is finalized, challenging factual inaccuracies or mischaracterizations of their pedagogical model.
- Ministry Review Conference: Requesting a formal conference with the regional Ministry Director of Education to present updated portfolio evidence.
- Office of the Ombudsman (Te Tari o te Kaitiaki Mana Tangata): Filing an administrative complaint under the Ombudsmen Act 1975 for official overreach, procedural unfairness, or failure to consider relevant evidence.
- Judicial Review: High Court judicial review under the Judicial Review Procedure Act 2016 if the Ministry acts unlawfully, irrationally, or in breach of statutory natural justice[1].
By maintaining systematic dated portfolios and demonstrating curriculum velocity, New Zealand home educators can confidently navigate ERO oversight while preserving full pedagogical autonomy[4].
Sources & Official References (4)
- New Zealand Legislation: Education and Training Act 2020 (Public Act 2020 No 38), Section 38 (Exemption from enrolment) and Section 457 (Review of education). Parliamentary Counsel Office. https://www.legislation.govt.nz/act/public/2020/0038/latest/LMS170204.html
- Education Review Office (ERO / Te Kahu Tōkeke): Home Schooling Review Framework and Accountability Guidelines. Crown Review Agency. https://www.ero.govt.nz/
- Ministry of Education (Te Tāhuhu o te Mātauranga): Home Education in New Zealand: Guidance, Application Procedures, and Supervisory Allowances. Crown Education Portal. https://www.education.govt.nz/school/school-terms-and-holiday-dates/home-education/
- National Home Education Support Network (NCHENZ): Legal Guidance for Exemption Applications, Annual Declarations, and ERO Audits. Official Community Support Hub. https://www.nchenz.org.nz/
Disclaimer: This post is for informational and educational purposes only, accurate to the best of our knowledge at publication. It does not constitute advice. We do not guarantee accuracy or completeness and accept no liability for any decisions or losses resulting from reliance on this content.




