Under the legal framework of New Zealand (Aotearoa), school attendance is compulsory for children aged six to sixteen pursuant to the Education and Training Act 2020[1]. However, Section 38 of the Act establishes a well-protected statutory exemption pathway. Parents may legally withdraw their child from conventional schooling upon obtaining an official Certificate of Exemption issued by the Ministry of Education (MOE - Te Tāhuhu o te Mātauranga)[1]. As examined in our previous analysis of Te Kura dual tuition pathways, holding an exemption certificate is the legal foundation for all home education in New Zealand.
Securing an exemption is neither an automatic right nor an informal notification; it requires the preparation of a rigorous, approval-ready Section 38 Application Dossier that satisfies the statutory legal threshold[2].
1. The Statutory Standard: “As Regularly and As Well”
Section 38(1) of the Education and Training Act 2020 defines the singular legal test that the Ministry of Education must apply when assessing an application[1]:
“The Secretary may grant a certificate of exemption if satisfied that the student will be taught at least as regularly and as well as in a registered school.”
- The “As Regularly” Requirement: Parents must demonstrate that instruction will occur with a consistency and dedication comparable to a registered school. This does not mean adhering to strict 9:00 AM to 3:00 PM school bells; rather, it requires showing a structured, sustainable routine totaling approximately 20 to 25 hours per week of planned educational engagement.
- The “As Well” Requirement: Parents must prove that the quality, breadth, and depth of instruction will provide an education comparable to that offered by registered primary or secondary schools. The Ministry assesses whether the child will acquire literacy, numeracy, critical inquiry, and social competence appropriate to their developmental stage.
- Focus on the Plan, Not the Parent: Ministry guidelines confirm that assessors evaluate the adequacy of the proposed educational plan, not the formal credentials of the parents. Parents are not required to hold teaching degrees or tertiary qualifications.
2. Structural Architecture of the Section 38 Dossier (Form EF19)
A comprehensive exemption application dossier (typically 12 to 25 pages) is structured across five mandatory pedagogical sections[2][3]:
- Educational Philosophy and Approach: A clear statement articulating the family’s educational values—whether classical, Charlotte Mason, unit study, Montessori-inspired, or eclectic. The philosophy must articulate why home education is chosen and how it supports the child’s unique developmental needs.
- Curriculum Architecture and Learning Areas: Detailed curriculum maps across the seven core learning areas of the New Zealand Curriculum (NZC): English, Mathematics and Statistics, Science, Social Sciences, The Arts, Health and Physical Education, and Technology[4].
- Weekly Timetable and Daily Routines: A plausible weekly timetable detailing dedicated blocks for direct instruction, independent reading, mathematical practice, physical activity, and community excursions.
- Comprehensive Resource Inventory: A specific, itemized inventory of textbooks, literature series, science equipment, digital learning platforms, library memberships, and community group memberships.
- Assessment and Record-Keeping Strategy: A detailed methodology explaining how the parent will monitor progress, adjust teaching velocity, and archive dated work samples (e.g., learning journals, dated math tests, photographic portfolios).
| Dossier Section | Ministry Assessment Focus | Key Evidence Required |
|---|---|---|
| Philosophy & Vision | Clear pedagogical intent | Alignment with child’s developmental profile |
| Curriculum Scope | Breadth and depth across subjects | Specific topic outlines for the next 12 months |
| Weekly Schedule | Regularity and sustainability | 20–25 hours/week structured learning schedule |
| Resource Inventory | Tangible instructional tools | Exact textbook titles, digital portals, local library |
| Assessment Plan | Continuous feedback & record-keeping | Portfolios, learning diaries, work samples rubrics |
Families structuring classical humanities and rich living-books sequences can explore our review of Charlotte Mason vs Classical Conversations to balance narrative study with structured recitations.
3. Navigating Requests for Further Information (RFIs)
Upon submitting the application to the local regional Ministry office, the dossier is reviewed by an MOE exemption assessor[2]:
- The Standard 4-to-6 Week Processing Window: The Ministry generally completes its assessment within four to six weeks. During this period, the child must remain enrolled in school unless an interim dispensation is agreed with the school principal.
- Handling Ministry RFIs (Request for Information): If the assessor feels specific sections are underdeveloped (most commonly math progression, special needs accommodations, or assessment logging), the Ministry issues a written RFI letter. Receiving an RFI is standard administrative practice, not a rejection.
- Responding to RFIs: Parents should respond point-by-point, providing concrete details (such as sample lesson outlines or specific textbook chapter lists) addressing the assessor’s exact concerns.
For families seeking an overview of state funding entitlements and indexing formulas available to exempt families, our guide on NZ homeschool supervision allowance indexation provides comprehensive details.
4. Issuance and Legal Protection of the Certificate of Exemption
Once the Ministry is satisfied, an official Certificate of Exemption under Section 38 is issued[1]:
- Enduring Validity: Unlike jurisdictions that require burdensome annual re-registration, a New Zealand Certificate of Exemption remains legally valid from the date of issue until the child turns sixteen, unless voluntarily surrendered or formally revoked by the Ministry.
- Supervision Allowance Qualification: The issuance of the certificate automatically qualifies the family to apply for the government Homeschool Supervision Allowance, paid in two semi-annual installments by the Ministry.
- Revocation Safeguards: The Ministry cannot arbitrarily cancel an exemption. Under Section 38(3), the Secretary can only revoke an exemption if satisfied that the student is no longer being taught as regularly and as well as in a registered school, following formal inquiry and opportunity to respond.
Parents exploring general international legal comparisons and foundational rights can consult our foundational overview of New Zealand homeschooling legal frameworks.
5. Frequently Asked Questions on NZ Section 38 Exemption Applications
Can a parent apply for an exemption before the child turns six years old?
Yes. While compulsory education begins at age six, parents are strongly encouraged to submit their Section 38 application when the child turns five, ensuring the exemption certificate is finalized before the mandatory sixth birthday.
Do parents need to own all listed curriculum materials before applying?
No. Assessors expect parents to identify specific titles, authors, and online platforms they plan to acquire or access via public libraries. Owning every single book prior to approval is not legally required.
Can an application be appealed if the Ministry ultimately declines the exemption?
Yes. If an application is declined, parents can request a formal review of the decision by the Ministry’s regional director. If unresolved, parents can submit a complaint to the Office of the Ombudsman to investigate administrative fairness and procedural propriety.
Sources & Official References (4)
- New Zealand Legislation: Education and Training Act 2020, Section 38 (Long-term exemptions from enrolment). https://www.legislation.govt.nz/
- Ministry of Education (MOE): Application for Exemption from Enrolment: Guidance and Criteria. https://www.education.govt.nz/
- National Council of Home Educators New Zealand: Exemption Application Manual and Resource Guide. https://www.nchenz.org.nz/
- Ministry of Education (TKI): The New Zealand Curriculum Framework: Key Competencies and Learning Areas. https://nzcurriculum.tki.org.nz/
Disclaimer: This post is for informational and educational purposes only, accurate to the best of our knowledge at publication. It does not constitute advice. We do not guarantee accuracy or completeness and accept no liability for any decisions or losses resulting from reliance on this content.




